In the modern landscape of education and community engagement, success has long been measured by outputs—metrics like the number of publications, course completions, or participants reached. While these indicators of process are essential, they often offer only a superficial view of the real-world change that such efforts can achieve. True impact extends beyond these processes, reaching deeper levels of personal and societal transformation. Impact affects various spheres: individuals who experience personal growth, families whose values and dynamics are enriched, communities that gain cohesion, institutions that drive meaningful progress, nations that grow in stability and well-being, and even the planet, which benefits from sustainable practices and global cooperation. By shifting our focus from process to impact, we can foster change that is both meaningful and lasting.
Understanding Impact
Impact in education and community work can be conceptualised as the tangible, enduring benefits that result from these initiatives, spanning multiple levels. At the personal level, education or community engagement fosters individual growth, strengthening personal values and building resilience (Bryson et al., 2020). This transformation often extends to family dynamics, where these newly acquired values shape interactions, fostering environments that support learning, empathy, and well-being (World Health Organization [WHO], 2017). At the community level, the process of engagement is critical; however, true impact occurs when communities transform in ways that reflect growth and shared values, addressing issues from literacy to healthcare access (Fraser et al., 2019). Institutional impact further amplifies this by driving policies, shaping curricula, and creating initiatives that reinforce societal values and equity. Nationally, impactful education produces skilled professionals and engaged citizens, contributing to financial stability, political resilience, and sustainable progress (UNESCO, 2015). Ultimately, the ripple effect of these transformations has the potential to address global challenges, fostering planetary health and sustainability (Crawford et al., 2021).
Why Impact Matters
Aligning Actions with Purpose
While output-based metrics track the processes of learning, such as course completion rates or publication counts, focusing on impact reorients efforts toward purpose. This approach ensures that educational and research activities are truly meaningful, working to create compassionate professionals, sustainable communities, or informed citizens. In medical education, for example, impact could be measured by improved patient outcomes rather than just the number of doctors trained (Bryson et al., 2020).
Creating Sustainable Change
A focus on impact cultivates changes that endure beyond the lifespan of a project. In community health, for example, a programme aimed at reducing disease prevalence may have sustainable impact if it results in long-term behavioural change, such as improved hygiene practices or healthier lifestyle choices among community members (Green et al., 2018). Sustainable transformation, as opposed to temporary gains, requires that the underlying values and practices endure over time, leading to lasting benefits for individuals and societies.
Encouraging Accountability
Evaluating impact holds educators, researchers, and community leaders accountable not only for the processes they initiate but also for the long-term effects of their work. Questions of impact shift the focus from quantitative outputs to qualitative change, asking whether a project has improved social values, supported financial sustainability, or contributed to political stability (UNESCO, 2015). This accountability framework enhances the integrity of educational and research programmes by ensuring they deliver genuine societal benefits.
Enhancing Financial and Social Value
Focusing on impact also supports the wise allocation of resources, with funding directed towards projects that yield significant, long-term benefits. Financial impact can be seen in economic resilience, as educational programmes improve employability and health initiatives reduce public healthcare costs (Crawford et al., 2021). Social value is equally crucial; by promoting equity, inclusion, and community welfare, impactful initiatives strengthen the social fabric and build resilience.
Addressing Global Challenges and Planetary Health
Educational and research institutions, by aligning with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), can actively contribute to planetary health and sustainability (UNESCO, 2015). For instance, research that advances environmental literacy or fosters sustainable practices directly supports global sustainability goals, emphasising that every local initiative has the potential to contribute to a healthier planet.
Measuring Impact Beyond Traditional Metrics
Impact measurement requires a nuanced approach, utilising tools and methods that capture both immediate and long-term effects across multiple domains. Personal growth can be assessed through reflective evaluations and surveys that track changes in values and behaviours (WHO, 2017). Community impact might involve participatory research methods that gather qualitative insights from community members, while financial sustainability can be gauged through Social Return on Investment (SROI) analyses, which quantify economic benefits against costs (Green et al., 2018). Policy analysis can measure political impact, tracing how research influences governance or legislative change (Bodilly et al., 2017). At the planetary level, environmental impact assessments aligned with SDG metrics allow institutions to measure contributions toward global sustainability (Crawford et al., 2021).
The Role of University Rankings in Measuring Impact
Increasingly, university ranking systems are recognising the importance of impact-focused metrics, moving beyond traditional outputs to capture the broader contributions of institutions to society and the environment. The Times Higher Education (THE) Impact Rankings evaluates universities based on their alignment with the United Nations Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), offering insights into how institutions address global challenges such as poverty and health (Times Higher Education, n.d.). The QS Stars University Rating System includes an “Impact” category that assesses community engagement and social responsibility (QS Quacquarelli Symonds, n.d.), while the UI GreenMetric World University Rankings specifically measures environmental sustainability practices on campuses (Universitas Indonesia, 2023). U-Multirank, funded by the European Commission, takes a multidimensional approach that includes regional engagement and knowledge transfer, allowing for a more nuanced assessment of local impact (U-Multirank, n.d.). These rankings encourage universities to prioritise sustainable practices, community engagement, and social responsibility, fostering a global movement towards impact-driven education.
A Future Built on Impact
As we navigate the future of education, research, and community engagement, a focus on impact is essential for creating meaningful, lasting change. This approach reframes educational initiatives as investments in personal development, family and social values, financial resilience, political stability, and planetary health. By integrating these dimensions into the core of educational and research efforts, institutions can drive progress on multiple fronts, fostering a more resilient, equitable, and sustainable society. In essence, a shift from process to impact enables us to fulfil not only the immediate goals of education and research but also the broader, transformative changes that these fields can inspire.
Disclaimer: This article was created using OpenAI’s ChatGPT for research and educational purposes.
References
Bodilly, S. J., Chun, J., Ikemoto, G. S., & Stockly, S. (2017). Improving school leadership: The promise of cohesive leadership systems. Rand Corporation.
Bryson, J. M., Patton, M. Q., & Bowman, R. A. (2020). Working across boundaries: Making collaboration work in government and nonprofit organizations. John Wiley & Sons.
Crawford, M., Hoque, Z., & Moll, J. (2021). Public sector reform and performance management: Managing on the edge. Routledge.
Fraser, N., Bunting, M., & O’Brien, M. (2019). Community engagement: Key to better health and education outcomes. World Health Organization.
Green, C., Hinton, P., & Ridley, M. (2018). Sustainable health and community development: Building resilience and equity. Oxford University Press.
QS Quacquarelli Symonds. (n.d.). QS Stars rating system. QS. https://www.qs.com/qs-stars/
Times Higher Education. (n.d.). Impact Rankings 2023. Times Higher Education. https://www.timeshighereducation.com/impactrankings
U-Multirank. (n.d.). What is U-Multirank? https://www.umultirank.org
UNESCO. (2015). Education 2030: Incheon declaration and framework for action towards inclusive and equitable quality education and lifelong learning for all. UNESCO.
Universitas Indonesia. (2023). UI GreenMetric World University Rankings 2023. Universitas Indonesia. https://greenmetric.ui.ac.id/
World Health Organization. (2017). Community engagement framework for quality, people-centered, and resilient health services. WHO.